• 0 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: April 12th, 2025

help-circle





  • Society has gotten far, far more unequal and oppressive

    By what metrics?

    Historically there simply wasn’t physical things with which to have the modern level of inequality. Historically the average lower end was was lower, but the modern high end is incomprehensible orders of magnitude higher.

    Historical acts of oppression were often far more brutal and cruel but that’s because it wasn’t physically possible to maintain the constant, but relatively minor oppression that is characteristic of modernity.



  • It’s axiomatic. The best means the best. Objectively. Fastest, highest, longest, game won.

    So your goalpost is a world record? No trans, non-binary, etc. individual I can find has set a world record in any sport.

    Participating in the Olympics, only to not even finish isn’t exactly winning though.

    If we lower the goalpost to ‘any trans, non-binary, etc. individual winning gold in the Olympics’ again nobody meets that criteria1. Dropping it to simply medaling? Again nothing.

    ^1 Quinn the soccer player arguably does meet this criteria, but it’s a team sport. Using that as your sole evidence of ‘loads of examples of the opposite’ seems extremely cherry picked doesn’t it?^




  • She was born as a woman and she considers herself a woman

    You are conflating sex and gender, she has 5α-reductase deficiency which exclusively effects individuals with an XY karyotype.

    Either all women1, including Semenya, fall under that umbrella or none of them do. Pick one.

    If your concern is about “unfair advantages gained via doping” then the majority of trans women competing are being much more fair because they are undergoing HRT to bring the “doping” back to within the typical woman baseline.

    Unless your moral outrage is because you’re drawing a distinction between naturally occuring and artificial doping?

    ^1 I should have to fucking say this, but based on the fact we’re having this conversation: this inherently includes trans women.^










  • Don’t underplay a regime and make them seem more reasonable than they are by whitewashing history

    That’s a better definition!

    But also don’t exaggerate a "regime"1 to make them seem more extreme than they are by whitewashing, decontextualizing, fabricating, using loaded language[1], etc.

    Propoganda often works explicitly via selectively presenting facts to encourage a particular synthesis or perception. What your are calling “details” and “minutia” are attempts to try and push back against some of that selectivity bias.