- 4 Posts
- 165 Comments
Is the ai doing anything that isn’t already allowed for humans. The thing is, generative ai doesn’t copy someone’s art. It’s more akin to learning from someone’s art and creating you own art with that influence. Given that we want to continue allowing hunans access to art for learning, what’s the logical difference to an ai doing the same?
AI stans always say stuff like this, but it doesn’t make sense to me at all.
AI does not learn the same way that a human does: it has no senses of its own with which to observe the world or art, it has no lived experiences, it has no agency, preferences or subjectivity, and it has no real intelligence with which to interpret or understand the work that it is copying from. AI is simply a matrix of weights that has arbitrary data superimposed on it by people and companies.
Are you an artist or a creative person?
If you are then you must know that the things you create are certainly indirectly influenced by SOME of the things that you have experienced (be it walking around on a sunny day, your favorite scene from your favorite movie, the lyrics of a song, etc.), AS WELL AS your own unique and creative persona, your own ideas, your own philosophy, and your own personal development.
Look at how an artist creates a painting and compare it to how generative AI creates a painting. Similarly, look at how artists train and learn their craft and compare it to how generative AI models are trained. It’s an apples-to-oranges comparison. Outside of the marketing labels of “artificial intelligence” and “machine learning”, it’s nothing like real intelligence or learning at all.
(And that’s still ignoring the obvious corporate element and the four pillars of fair use consideration (US law, not UK, mind you). For example, the potential market effects of generating an automated system which uses people’s artwork to directly compete against them.)
Either get rid of copyright for everything and everyone, or don’t.
But no stupid BULLSHIT exception for AI slop.
Does anyone know what reciprocal means?
Just checking.
It’s not a surprise that all these techbros who want to steal everything and feed it into their AI machines without paying a single fucking cent to the original creators all the sudden want to get rid of IP. They can lead by example by submitting their IP into the public domain.
Or maybe they’re just massive frauds?
AI isn’t ready to replace just about anybody’s job, and probably never will be technically, economically or legally viable.
That said, the c-suit class are certainly going to try. Not only do they dream of optimizing all human workers out of every workforce, they also desperately need to recoup as much of the sunk cost that they’ve collectively dumped into the technology.
Take OpenAI for example, they lost something like $5,000,000,000 last year and are probably going to lose even more this year. Their entire business plan relies on at least selling people on the idea that AI will be able to replace human workers. The minute people realize that OpenAI isn’t going to conquer the world, and instead end up as just one of many players in the slop space, the entire bottom will fall out of the company and the AI bubble will burst.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto Technology@lemmy.world•Dear Big Tech, Stop Shoving AI Into Operating SystemsEnglish391·3 months agoBig tech will do what is best for extracting money customers and investors.
If you really care what your operating system is made of, use Linux.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto World News@lemmy.world•Live updates: Trump announces sweeping tariffsEnglish762·4 months agoWhy the fuck is our media so bad that they blindly accept Trump’s bullshit line that the tariffs are “reciprocal”? Are they just stupid or have they been paid off? Do they not know the meaning of “reciprocal” or are they just too fucking lazy to question the White House’s rhetoric even a little bit?
The state of the United States makes me sick. We’re being robbed blind by the oligarchy in broad daylight while the media gleefully amplifies the administrations lies.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•Pete Hegseth denies texting war plans to journalist572·4 months agoThese fucking guys only ever lie and deny.
Are we really too stupid and weak as a country to be able to do anything about this?
maplebar@lemmy.worldto Fediverse@lemmy.world•There's a clear up tick on daily users growing and we've crossed the 50k line as of yesterday! LETSSS GOOO!English28·5 months agoTHERE ARE DOZENS OF US!!
But seriously this is good news and I’m glad to have you all here. Lemmy is in a pretty good position right now in terms of having a critical mass of users and decent traction within popular communities. At the very least it feels self-sustaining here.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•Billionaires at Trump’s swearing-in have since lost $209 billion19·5 months agoThey deserve to lose so much more.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•Dow tumbles 900 points, Nasdaq drops 4% as market sell-off intensifies on recession fears: Live updates2·5 months agoTo be totally honest, this isn’t about stock market gamesmanship to me–I’m not trying to buy the dip over the next few days. (If anything I’m waiting for the AI bubble, which I personally believe is bigger than the .com bubble, to blow the fuck up.)
Between incompetent idiots and assholes running everything, ridiculously inflated stock prices, meme stocks and market manipulation, on-again-off-again trade war bullshit, and the AI bubble, I’m happy to have my money out of the market. I have zero faith in the people who are running our economy to do anything worth investing in, and I’ll be perfectly happy to find alternative means of investing over the next 2-4 years.
Frankly, I’m sick of putting almost my entire life savings in the hands of corporations and the delusional k-holed fucknuts like Musk who run them. It’s a bonus that I’m no longer the shameful owner of bullshit ETFs and company shares that serve only to enrich and empower the richest corporate oligarchs.
I’ve lived through multiple crashes already, maybe I’ll hop back into the stock market during the next one, or maybe not because fuck this whole system.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•Dow tumbles 900 points, Nasdaq drops 4% as market sell-off intensifies on recession fears: Live updates3·5 months agoI sold all of my stocks a couple weeks back and I’m feeling pretty fucking good about that right now.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•Dow tumbles 900 points, Nasdaq drops 4% as market sell-off intensifies on recession fears: Live updates91·5 months agoMargin of error +/-52%.
Duplicate communities are a good thing anyway.
It’s crazy that on Reddit a community can get hijacked by some fucking weirdo who has control of things basically forever.
I think you should contact the moderation team. I’d be really curious to hear what they have to say is “excessive” about you informing people of EU-based alternatives to Reddit…
If nothing else it’ll be a good laugh here on fedi.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto Technology@lemmy.world•CEO of Brave rants about "lefties," "glowies," George SorosEnglish671·5 months agoJesus, this fucking paranoid bitch can barely string a sentence together. He must be neck deep in the techbro CEO k-hole…
Also, as an Irish leftist, he should leave my people out of his delusional and incoherent ranting.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•FiveThirtyEight Gets the Ax as ABC News Slashes Jobs in Major Shakeup12·5 months agoI’m not sure there was much value in the type of tea-leaf reading that 538 was known to do, but then again, I’m not sure how much value there is in corporate political news in general.
maplebar@lemmy.worldto News@lemmy.world•EU must 'urgently' rearm and turn Ukraine into 'steel porcupine': VDL1·5 months agoAlmost not worth living (if not for pizza and weed gummies).
maplebar@lemmy.worldto World News@lemmy.world•Japan ‘on verge of no longer functioning’ after birth rate plummets to record new lowEnglish1·5 months agoJokes on you, I don’t have healthcare.
I’ll only add to this that Toh Enjoe is a famous Japanese scifi literature writer who has won one of Japan’s most prestigious literary awards, the Akutagawa Prize, as well as the 2012 Nihon SF Taisho award.
I’m not sure that his Space Dandy episodes are my favorites in that series, but it’ll be cool to see what he comes up with in the world of GitS.